I used all three on my own yard for 30 days. Leaves, pine needles, grass clippings and everyday debris. One made me question why I was still raking by hand.

So I bought all three and used each one for a month. Worst to best, here is how they actually ranked.

Solid build, and it picks up well. But the hopper is small for its size, so you stop to empty it constantly. Fine on a small yard, rough on a big one.

The lightest and easiest to push, and it stores anywhere. Great on a small lawn. But the narrow sweep means more passes, and it fills up fast.

Widest sweep, biggest hopper, and a new bristle setup that grabs more in one pass. What took me an hour with a rake now takes ten minutes. This is the one.
Why The 30-Inch Won
The 30-inch runs a wider, denser row of bristles than the other two.

More bristles on the grass at once means one pass instead of three. Less time, less bending, same clean yard.
All three beat a rake. But the 30-inch is the one I kept grabbing. It's the fastest way I've found to get my Saturday back, and right now it's $100 off for the End of Summer Sale.
End of Summer Sale
Only while End of Summer stock lasts. Once it's gone, pricing goes back up.